Elasticsearch doesn't find bundled JDK

[dandago]

Elasticsearch version (bin/elasticsearch --version):

7.1.1 and 7.2.0.

Version: 7.1.1, Build: default/zip/7a013de/2019-05-23T14:04:00.380842Z, JVM: 12.0.1
Version: 7.2.0, Build: default/zip/508c38a/2019-06-20T15:54:18.811730Z, JVM: 12.0.1

Plugins installed: []

Nothing extra. Just vanilla Elasticsearch.

JVM version (java -version):

Whatever is bundled with the respective versions (see Elasticsearch version output above).

OS version (uname -a if on a Unix-like system):

Windows 10 Home
Build 17134.829

Description of the problem including expected versus actual behavior:

Even though the JDK is bundled with Elasticsearch as from version 7.0, I still have to set JAVA_HOME for it to work. Elasticsearch complains that it can't find Java bundled at the directory where it actually exists. See the thread I posted at Discuss Elastic which shows the output with Elasticsearch 7.1.1.

Steps to reproduce:

1. Open cmd.exe
2. Navigate to the Elasticsearch bin folder
3. Run elasticsearch.bat

Provide logs (if relevant):

N/A

[elasticmachine]

Pinging @elastic/es-core-infra

[rjernst]

@dandago Can you please check you do not already have a JAVA_HOME set? Something like echo %JAVA_HOME% just before running elasticsearch.bat. If that is not set, can you then try running from the elasticsearch home directory instead of within the bin directory? I'm trying to narrow down where this issue might be, but I rely on our windows packaging tests, which are passing, so I'm hoping to get some more data points to help in crafting a test that would fail.

[dandago]

@rjernst You are right, I did have JAVA_HOME set to a directory that no longer exists. It works if I clear it.

In this case, I'm afraid the error:

could not find java in JAVA_HOME or bundled at C:\tools\elasticsearch-7.1.1\jdk

...is misleading. I would have thought that if it fails to find the JDK in JAVA_HOME then it would look for the bundled one (which exists at the directory it is mentioning), but it seems to be relying entirely on JAVA_HOME if it is set.

[1044886782]

this is my problem , i can't figure it out...

[1044886782]

this is my problem , i can't figure it out...

I finally find a way to slove this probem: the url is:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/49012969/could-not-find-java-home-elastcisearch

execute this command: set JAVA_HOME=D:\java

[cawoodm]

This is still an issue (Windows 10) ES 7.3.0:

As you can see it can find java (where it says it can't) only if we set JAVA_HOME.

In my case JAVA_HOME was already set to a JRE path so, if ES doesn't like that, it should find it's own packaged JDK.

[rjernst]

@cawoodm If JAVA_HOME is set, Elasticsearch will use that. There is no attempt to discern whether the version of is meant to be used with Elasticsearch. If you don't mean to use that java with Elasticsearch, unset JAVA_HOME when starting ES.

[1044886782]

@cawoodm If JAVA_HOME is set, Elasticsearch will use that. There is no attempt to discern whether the version of is meant to be used with Elasticsearch. If you don't mean to use that java with Elasticsearch, unset JAVA_HOME when starting ES.

Yes，I've sloved this problem by setting this PATH,thanks.

[dandago]

@rjernst

@cawoodm If JAVA_HOME is set, Elasticsearch will use that. There is no attempt to discern whether the version of is meant to be used with Elasticsearch. If you don't mean to use that java with Elasticsearch, unset JAVA_HOME when starting ES.

If this is the behaviour, then the error shouldn't claim that it checked for the bundled JDK.

[rjernst]

If this is the behaviour, then the error shouldn't claim that it checked for the bundled JDK.

I agree. The existing error message is a result of only slightly changing the old error message where we looked for JAVA_HOME and on the PATH. I will separate this out so it is clear when JAVA_HOME was used and that the path does not exist.

[filmico]

These was the steps I followed to run ElasticSearch 7.13.2 on windows 10

1. Download the Java SDK from:
   https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase-jdk16-downloads.html
   scroll down and download de installer for windows

   JDK by default will be installed in C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-16.0.1
   and the java.exe will reside inside the bin folder of that installation

2. Now we need to make JavaSDK visible for all the system, so we need to add the path to the environment variables. I set this as Systems Variables no users variables

   Path add an extra path pointing to: C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-16.0.1\bin
   add a new System variables called ES_JAVA_HOME and pointing to C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-16.0.1\

3. Run Elastic Search with CMD

   cd C:{your-elastic-search-folder}\elasticsearch-7.13.2\bin
   elasticsearch.bat