Elasticsearch identifying non polygon area as a part of polygon #105591
Description
Elasticsearch Version
7.7.0
Installed Plugins
No response
Java Version
1.8
OS Version
Amazon Linux 2
Problem Description
I have created a field of type geo_shape in Elasticsearch. It stores an array of latitude and longitude values to create a polygon. My use case is to search for users based on their location (latitude and longitude) and determine if they are inside the polygon or not. However, sometimes Elasticsearch considers all areas as part of the polygon, which is causing issues.
Steps to Reproduce
Below is the index mapping for the polygons:
{ "closed-regions": { "mappings": { "properties": { "location": { "type": "geo_shape" }, "propertyIds": { "type": "nested", "properties": { "id": { "type": "integer" }, "time_from": { "type": "date", "format": "HH:mm:ss" }, "time_to": { "type": "date", "format": "HH:mm:ss" } } }, "title": { "type": "text" } } }, "settings": { "index": { "creation_date": "1654766211880", "number_of_shards": "5", "number_of_replicas": "1", "uuid": "KHMf2ceuRme6U5H1FXlYSw", "version": { "created": "7070099" }, "provided_name": "closed-regions" } } } }
and the polygon data which causes the above issue are:
{ "location": { "type": "polygon", "coordinates": [ [ [ 73.154866320844, 33.655045737865 ], [ 73.064573854208, 33.570837907056 ], [ 73.063834905624, 33.570596545721 ], [ 73.06327432394, 33.570450164212 ], [ 73.062076717615, 33.570142873979 ], [ 73.06076914072, 33.569833347802 ], [ 73.058848679066, 33.569262341725 ], [ 73.057763725519, 33.568953929827 ], [ 73.056644392624, 33.568645342228 ], [ 73.055862039328, 33.568342689948 ], [ 73.054574579, 33.567778378723 ], [ 73.054262223369, 33.567661989074 ], [ 73.054004609585, 33.567634227344 ], [ 73.053747117519, 33.567621935354 ], [ 73.053178489208, 33.567621935354 ], [ 73.052352195768, 33.567697747567 ], [ 73.052742630243, 33.567290050983 ], [ 73.053382323013, 33.566723323344 ], [ 73.053886656144, 33.566392552989 ], [ 73.054605599117, 33.565731008476 ], [ 73.054960817099, 33.565508804651 ], [ 73.055367171764, 33.565288660614 ], [ 73.056599646807, 33.565821698762 ], [ 73.05680885911, 33.565878690068 ], [ 73.057062881817, 33.565865105746 ], [ 73.057245300184, 33.565784647409 ], [ 73.057352605105, 33.565605850836 ], [ 73.057352605105, 33.565409174178 ], [ 73.057009229357, 33.564238044803 ], [ 73.056975156069, 33.563944317086 ], [ 73.0569845438, 33.56377445673 ], [ 73.057024776936, 33.563668293839 ], [ 73.057085126638, 33.563534193157 ], [ 73.057266761168, 33.563308281928 ], [ 73.058436384811, 33.562414269724 ], [ 73.059337770992, 33.561645411825 ], [ 73.059998005629, 33.560782848208 ], [ 73.060834854841, 33.559783759747 ], [ 73.061986863613, 33.558357747695 ], [ 73.061840683222, 33.558117469051 ], [ 73.061685115099, 33.557867131521 ], [ 73.061530888081, 33.557619028432 ], [ 73.061351180077, 33.557380982907 ], [ 73.061025291681, 33.557025589774 ], [ 73.060698062181, 33.556678018346 ], [ 73.061029314995, 33.556813247267 ], [ 73.061646223068, 33.557071410983 ], [ 73.062096834183, 33.557179817162 ], [ 73.062728494406, 33.557326221167 ], [ 73.063460737467, 33.556190745437 ], [ 73.063590824604, 33.556047692318 ], [ 73.063662215632, 33.55595028614 ], [ 73.06371152401, 33.555838700226 ], [ 73.063755780458, 33.555747056475 ], [ 73.063766509295, 33.555659883061 ], [ 73.063732981682, 33.555447537197 ], [ 73.063662215632, 33.555235016184 ], [ 73.063624352217, 33.555143546421 ], [ 73.063640754648, 33.555029374976 ], [ 73.063785284758, 33.554608207121 ], [ 73.063924759626, 33.554269566978 ], [ 73.06406510021, 33.553930279378 ], [ 73.064103126526, 33.553766633624 ], [ 73.064215779305, 33.553224579952 ], [ 73.064344525337, 33.552499228584 ], [ 73.064387014974, 33.552276169939 ], [ 73.064685165882, 33.550573497332 ], [ 73.064879626036, 33.549645822733 ], [ 73.064846098423, 33.549103743206 ], [ 73.064856827259, 33.548937206751 ], [ 73.064917176962, 33.548722608967 ], [ 73.065226972103, 33.547926804196 ], [ 73.065358128653, 33.547546136301 ], [ 73.065309841438, 33.547295768136 ], [ 73.065229362747, 33.547072224519 ], [ 73.065052321057, 33.546466741503 ], [ 73.065036225319, 33.546381794182 ], [ 73.065025494827, 33.546229782978 ], [ 73.06502817745, 33.546118009863 ], [ 73.06502817745, 33.546024120334 ], [ 73.065068416795, 33.54588999226 ], [ 73.065384966313, 33.545143342173 ], [ 73.065350092214, 33.54505839355 ], [ 73.065283026638, 33.545002506253 ], [ 73.064534574811, 33.544971209351 ], [ 73.063987319712, 33.545036038636 ], [ 73.06363874267, 33.544953325402 ], [ 73.063330241021, 33.544901909028 ], [ 73.062278842412, 33.542778162487 ], [ 73.062099236671, 33.542429415962 ], [ 73.062008321285, 33.542302312104 ], [ 73.06190340519, 33.542185739669 ], [ 73.061798782891, 33.542024778806 ], [ 73.061586855671, 33.541772159068 ], [ 73.061535885834, 33.541693913867 ], [ 73.061503694357, 33.541615668595 ], [ 73.06144467665, 33.541354105314 ], [ 73.061409802551, 33.541155137844 ], [ 73.06146517396, 33.540827946092 ], [ 73.061538565559, 33.540524698566 ], [ 73.061568074412, 33.540433038572 ], [ 73.061637822611, 33.540319022346 ], [ 73.061516135931, 33.540236627714 ], [ 73.06140884757, 33.540430008271 ], [ 73.06119158864, 33.540380824818 ], [ 73.059708327055, 33.541687530243 ], [ 73.059800863266, 33.541751244203 ], [ 73.059461563826, 33.542004981786 ], [ 73.059405237436, 33.541961388158 ], [ 73.059263080359, 33.542082108922 ], [ 73.058805763721, 33.541627169607 ], [ 73.058292727899, 33.541486004846 ], [ 73.057873696089, 33.54135219284 ], [ 73.057523667812, 33.541067155024 ], [ 73.057590723038, 33.540371882369 ], [ 73.05792465806, 33.539819684346 ], [ 73.058679699898, 33.539854336552 ], [ 73.059202730656, 33.53915234721 ], [ 73.059352934361, 33.538710806406 ], [ 73.059497773647, 33.538278206014 ], [ 73.059977889061, 33.537998747245 ], [ 73.060368150473, 33.538552074731 ], [ 73.060640394688, 33.538501772378 ], [ 73.060942143202, 33.538448116504 ], [ 73.061347156763, 33.538101588177 ], [ 73.061757534742, 33.537749469261 ], [ 73.061998933554, 33.537563907604 ], [ 73.061908153288, 33.537428002301 ], [ 73.061108440161, 33.537815421802 ], [ 73.060958504734, 33.537159719262 ], [ 73.060631006956, 33.536485182856 ], [ 73.060782551765, 33.536435997158 ], [ 73.060533106327, 33.535905013408 ], [ 73.060282319784, 33.535374026398 ], [ 73.059857189655, 33.534828503715 ], [ 73.059418742871, 33.534405298568 ], [ 73.059035092592, 33.534180132114 ], [ 73.058964014053, 33.533996798573 ], [ 73.058568388224, 33.533768748991 ], [ 73.058127164841, 33.533538463018 ], [ 73.057283610106, 33.533102483041 ], [ 73.057133406401, 33.53305553122 ], [ 73.056973814964, 33.533025347893 ], [ 73.056712299585, 33.533013050979 ], [ 73.056405186653, 33.533051059617 ], [ 73.055828511715, 33.533130430541 ], [ 73.055343031883, 33.533200858202 ], [ 73.055076661824, 33.533291233296 ], [ 73.054540137217, 33.533514812558 ], [ 73.052840530872, 33.534436127689 ], [ 73.05261656642, 33.53418125 ], [ 73.05239662528, 33.533891716977 ], [ 73.051997010579, 33.533237574187 ], [ 73.051420301199, 33.53219138958 ], [ 73.051417564004, 33.53177087898 ], [ 73.051418960094, 33.531721865275 ], [ 73.051473945379, 33.531614545076 ], [ 73.051516860724, 33.531523993554 ], [ 73.051687180996, 33.531294819526 ], [ 73.055013120174, 33.531434559859 ], [ 73.056163787842, 33.531288111984 ], [ 73.056183904409, 33.53082976207 ], [ 73.056213408709, 33.530370291791 ], [ 73.056261688471, 33.529453579803 ], [ 73.056068569422, 33.52910030771 ], [ 73.055892884731, 33.52875485987 ], [ 73.055548220873, 33.528059488187 ], [ 73.055336326361, 33.527623480582 ], [ 73.055129796267, 33.527181880895 ], [ 73.055136501789, 33.526740278953 ], [ 73.055144548416, 33.526309854637 ], [ 73.056278382304, 33.526311767444 ], [ 73.056289112796, 33.525826559294 ], [ 73.057417797557, 33.525828472112 ], [ 73.057439258541, 33.525121896864 ], [ 73.05841036808, 33.524969848271 ], [ 73.059363663197, 33.524917948351 ], [ 73.059517890215, 33.524911240315 ], [ 73.059666752815, 33.524921302369 ], [ 73.05996628944, 33.524943016139 ], [ 73.060577927492, 33.524969848271 ], [ 73.06062027812, 33.525001798762 ], [ 73.060624301434, 33.525047636952 ], [ 73.060813397169, 33.525001798762 ], [ 73.06099105144, 33.524987736355 ], [ 73.061270044235, 33.524960904228 ], [ 73.061403483152, 33.524961550575 ], [ 73.061591959, 33.525139784916 ], [ 73.061913873764, 33.525296305215 ], [ 73.061994352455, 33.525305249224 ], [ 73.062144579345, 33.525072704702 ], [ 73.062646687031, 33.524931364423 ], [ 73.06349426508, 33.524870992086 ], [ 73.064136654139, 33.525112481179 ], [ 73.064306459684, 33.524916183998 ], [ 73.064498752356, 33.524469626778 ], [ 73.064682026909, 33.523963637609 ], [ 73.064846098423, 33.523490242888 ], [ 73.064911812544, 33.523378440368 ], [ 73.064992278814, 33.523266637705 ], [ 73.06511297822, 33.523149244752 ], [ 73.06526683873, 33.523028969218 ], [ 73.065927028656, 33.522494077348 ], [ 73.06621670723, 33.522231338173 ], [ 73.066393540405, 33.522058513358 ], [ 73.066577464342, 33.52181430797 ], [ 73.067150040101, 33.522134540247 ], [ 73.067569881678, 33.52238339158 ], [ 73.067804600122, 33.522577283744 ], [ 73.067874348321, 33.522657782318 ], [ 73.067922592163, 33.523096697379 ], [ 73.067907840014, 33.523327011161 ], [ 73.067772408645, 33.523878668173 ], [ 73.068496616672, 33.524138048296 ], [ 73.068712502718, 33.524186769328 ], [ 73.068782240152, 33.524208011619 ], [ 73.068846613169, 33.524247142142 ], [ 73.068856088159, 33.524334818905 ], [ 73.068748783237, 33.524661278246 ], [ 73.06853953864, 33.52502798453 ], [ 73.06814789772, 33.525311485573 ], [ 73.068019109772, 33.52534549725 ], [ 73.067569881678, 33.52571396497 ], [ 73.06699052453, 33.526152218182 ], [ 73.066712915897, 33.526392585711 ], [ 73.066591954317, 33.52657976098 ], [ 73.067187496631, 33.527089560422 ], [ 73.06728407106, 33.527241605289 ], [ 73.067364549751, 33.527465200194 ], [ 73.0674277246, 33.527786704199 ], [ 73.067461252213, 33.528116504404 ], [ 73.068418800831, 33.528823055184 ], [ 73.068142533302, 33.529778901877 ], [ 73.069208711386, 33.530246200859 ], [ 73.068881481886, 33.530810757265 ], [ 73.068603873253, 33.531317177994 ], [ 73.068416220785, 33.531449564464 ], [ 73.067982941866, 33.532061711694 ], [ 73.067567199469, 33.532408264232 ], [ 73.067194372416, 33.532711217087 ], [ 73.067009299994, 33.533217626684 ], [ 73.066844203686, 33.53364960612 ], [ 73.066731533519, 33.53378375319 ], [ 73.066516923676, 33.533850826648 ], [ 73.066682070494, 33.535911720592 ], [ 73.066888600588, 33.536925617177 ], [ 73.067340552807, 33.537079880444 ], [ 73.068343698978, 33.537250911136 ], [ 73.068986088037, 33.537686870192 ], [ 73.070304393768, 33.53636668999 ], [ 73.071597218514, 33.535047607501 ], [ 73.072038441896, 33.535308071994 ], [ 73.072012960911, 33.536339861394 ], [ 73.072012960911, 33.537341456659 ], [ 73.072045147419, 33.539345730193 ], [ 73.071154654026, 33.539715727643 ], [ 73.070296347141, 33.540060013878 ], [ 73.070178329945, 33.540132671513 ], [ 73.069809526205, 33.540181855107 ], [ 73.06971564889, 33.540207564702 ], [ 73.069648593664, 33.540545142155 ], [ 73.069548010826, 33.540869304693 ], [ 73.06932002306, 33.541062683835 ], [ 73.069267719984, 33.541237060031 ], [ 73.069301420971, 33.541300128098 ], [ 73.069228827953, 33.541315305646 ], [ 73.069183385558, 33.541349311028 ], [ 73.069164454937, 33.541756833144 ], [ 73.069051802158, 33.541801544664 ], [ 73.068944513798, 33.542141351458 ], [ 73.069066554308, 33.542397323456 ], [ 73.069149702787, 33.542404030136 ], [ 73.069203346968, 33.542704712408 ], [ 73.069246262312, 33.542863436458 ], [ 73.069282472134, 33.543091462046 ], [ 73.069332093, 33.543224476695 ], [ 73.069393783808, 33.543300484974 ], [ 73.069416582584, 33.543364197745 ], [ 73.06942731142, 33.543471503357 ], [ 73.069440722466, 33.543631343762 ], [ 73.06946888566, 33.543955494725 ], [ 73.069743812084, 33.543948788165 ], [ 73.069782704115, 33.544413775046 ], [ 73.069824278355, 33.544877641676 ], [ 73.070349991322, 33.544842991484 ], [ 73.070395588875, 33.545728243654 ], [ 73.069886232793, 33.545941084951 ], [ 73.069912380858, 33.546240637187 ], [ 73.070277217591, 33.547081166275 ], [ 73.070140779018, 33.547215938681 ], [ 73.070163577795, 33.547334416673 ], [ 73.070186376572, 33.547461836219 ], [ 73.070423752069, 33.547698791366 ], [ 73.070253431797, 33.547932392739 ], [ 73.070138096809, 33.548079930122 ], [ 73.070050925016, 33.548153698719 ], [ 73.069692485261, 33.548333002952 ], [ 73.069572150707, 33.548472244211 ], [ 73.069498389959, 33.548473361913 ], [ 73.069569084601, 33.549343400757 ], [ 73.069574449848, 33.54955352625 ], [ 73.069399148226, 33.550381257149 ], [ 73.069220054935, 33.551122099005 ], [ 73.069089353085, 33.5516978703 ], [ 73.068908303976, 33.552266757211 ], [ 73.068670928478, 33.552913875489 ], [ 73.068332970142, 33.553737575163 ], [ 73.068048655987, 33.554338859789 ], [ 73.06846305728, 33.554546737887 ], [ 73.068641424179, 33.554466269005 ], [ 73.068819791079, 33.554386917673 ], [ 73.069077283144, 33.554317624901 ], [ 73.069385737181, 33.554648441505 ], [ 73.069777339697, 33.554466269005 ], [ 73.069873899221, 33.554422681663 ], [ 73.069957047701, 33.554409270168 ], [ 73.070113956928, 33.554377976674 ], [ 73.070359379053, 33.554338859789 ], [ 73.070451915264, 33.554322095404 ], [ 73.070583254706, 33.554331979407 ], [ 73.070969581604, 33.556277918315 ], [ 73.07136118412, 33.557547503085 ], [ 73.071696460247, 33.558834950274 ], [ 73.071898967028, 33.560352593409 ], [ 73.07283103466, 33.561206395645 ], [ 73.076473342644, 33.561252040021 ], [ 73.079283088446, 33.561378496121 ], [ 73.080341219902, 33.561423197487 ], [ 73.080358654261, 33.561547243657 ], [ 73.080345243216, 33.561675759771 ], [ 73.080274164677, 33.561994255404 ], [ 73.080530315638, 33.562278106662 ], [ 73.080765539501, 33.562593072905 ], [ 73.080983608961, 33.562932972541 ], [ 73.081131130457, 33.563208998139 ], [ 73.081281334162, 33.563486140362 ], [ 73.081568330526, 33.564015837136 ], [ 73.07970687747, 33.564773499026 ], [ 73.079018890858, 33.565071868476 ], [ 73.078238368034, 33.565542329074 ], [ 73.077652305365, 33.565936798811 ], [ 73.077237904072, 33.566211697335 ], [ 73.077052746162, 33.566383613232 ], [ 73.076932132244, 33.566500004604 ], [ 73.07687446475, 33.566558112929 ], [ 73.076828867197, 33.566617338682 ], [ 73.076649159193, 33.566940285939 ], [ 73.076548576355, 33.567229708233 ], [ 73.07635679841, 33.567714683957 ], [ 73.075415343046, 33.567210711433 ], [ 73.074512779713, 33.566729085274 ], [ 73.07279214263, 33.565195909405 ], [ 73.072692900896, 33.565647372183 ], [ 73.07265534997, 33.566048546284 ], [ 73.072489053011, 33.566048546284 ], [ 73.072309868636, 33.566079660946 ], [ 73.072266429663, 33.566082070498 ], [ 73.072257041931, 33.566031784172 ], [ 73.072187304497, 33.565979262868 ], [ 73.072041606332, 33.565882985367 ], [ 73.071544915438, 33.565961383267 ], [ 73.071114420891, 33.56602843175 ], [ 73.071088939905, 33.565389234102 ], [ 73.071066141129, 33.564738856813 ], [ 73.070716112852, 33.564100767118 ], [ 73.070049583912, 33.563649296255 ], [ 73.06938841939, 33.563201175563 ], [ 73.06806743145, 33.562309397295 ], [ 73.067874312401, 33.562701646766 ], [ 73.067699968815, 33.563069309182 ], [ 73.067053556442, 33.563610183569 ], [ 73.066456764936, 33.564058302137 ], [ 73.066120147705, 33.564219221954 ], [ 73.06576743722, 33.564376788983 ], [ 73.066016882658, 33.564780203968 ], [ 73.066271692514, 33.565166854789 ], [ 73.066822886467, 33.565928976482 ], [ 73.066934198141, 33.566132356794 ], [ 73.067024052143, 33.566342441449 ], [ 73.067066967487, 33.566496652199 ], [ 73.067083060741, 33.566653097607 ], [ 73.06707338019, 33.566973635203 ], [ 73.066604286432, 33.568162781226 ], [ 73.066425919533, 33.568753908479 ], [ 73.06626859328, 33.569351561673 ], [ 73.065969944, 33.569732779491 ], [ 73.065524697304, 33.570076946114 ], [ 73.064573854208, 33.570837907056 ], [ 73.154867738485, 33.655045179705 ], [ 73.167210753664, 33.484962369701 ], [ 72.952257535101, 33.481812553725 ], [ 72.956721419831, 33.640306249188 ], [ 73.154866320844, 33.655045737865 ] ] ] } }
User location is:
longitude: 73.0623258
latitude: 33.5573597
Elasticsearch returns a point within a polygon area, but the user's location is outside of that polygon area.
I am using the following elasticsearch query for this:
{ "size": 500, "query": { "bool": { "filter": { "geo_shape": { "location": { "shape": { "type": "Point", "coordinates": [ 73.0623258, 33.5573597 ] }, "relation": "contains" } } } } }, "script_fields": { "propertyIds": { "script": { "id": "find-polygon-by-coordinates", "params": { "current_time": "16:58:06" } } } } }
Please help me find the solution to my problem.
Logs (if relevant)
No response