Skip to content

Distributed remote references + precompilation #53

@quinnj

Description

@quinnj

Currently remote refs (RemoteChannel, Future) are a bit of a silent killer if used in precompiled module. Though our precompilation docs spell out in great detail the various constructors/patterns that should be avoided, nothing is mentioned of remote refs.

Digging into the implementation, however, reveals that remote refs use a global counter for self-identifying. It seems there's also likely to be issues with the worker id of the remote ref, but I didn't personally run into that (in my use-case, I was always creating RemoteChannels on pid 1 as "config variables" that all other worker processes could reference).

The problem identifies itself by producing invalid results: e.g. the first Future on pid 1 created at runtime will probably match the exact RRID of a precompiled RemoteChannel and hence isready, wait, fetch return results of the precompiled RemoteChannel instead of the Future. Quite a lovely surprise!

Obviously we want to avoid this situation of things seeming completely broken, so if that involves throwing explicit errors when precompiling a module w/ global RemoteChannel or Future variables, that seems safest to me. I'm not aware of all the precompilation magic that is available though in the case that we could actually make this work.

Ultimately, I think something more than just docs here.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions