gh-113951: Tkinter: "tag_unbind(tag, sequence, funcid)" now only unbinds "funcid" (GH-113955)

Previously, "tag_unbind(tag, sequence, funcid)" methods of Text and
Canvas widgets destroyed the current binding for "sequence", leaving
"sequence" unbound, and deleted the "funcid" command.

Now they remove only "funcid" from the binding for "sequence", keeping
other commands, and delete the "funcid" command.
They leave "sequence" unbound only if "funcid" was the last bound command.

Author: serhiy-storchaka

Lib/test/test_tkinter/test_misc.py

@@ -706,6 +706,101 @@ def test3(e): pass
         self.assertCommandExist(funcid2)
         self.assertCommandExist(funcid3)
 
+    def _test_tag_bind(self, w):
+        tag = 'sel'
+        event = '<Control-Alt-Key-a>'
+        w.pack()
+        self.assertRaises(TypeError, w.tag_bind)
+        tag_bind = w._tag_bind if isinstance(w, tkinter.Text) else w.tag_bind
+        if isinstance(w, tkinter.Text):
+            self.assertRaises(TypeError, w.tag_bind, tag)
+            self.assertRaises(TypeError, w.tag_bind, tag, event)
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag), ())
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag, event), '')
+        def test1(e): pass
+        def test2(e): pass
+
+        funcid = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test1)
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag), (event,))
+        script = tag_bind(tag, event)
+        self.assertIn(funcid, script)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid)
+
+        funcid2 = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test2, add=True)
+        script = tag_bind(tag, event)
+        self.assertIn(funcid, script)
+        self.assertIn(funcid2, script)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid2)
+
+    def _test_tag_unbind(self, w):
+        tag = 'sel'
+        event = '<Control-Alt-Key-b>'
+        w.pack()
+        tag_bind = w._tag_bind if isinstance(w, tkinter.Text) else w.tag_bind
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag), ())
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag, event), '')
+        def test1(e): pass
+        def test2(e): pass
+
+        funcid = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test1)
+        funcid2 = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test2, add=True)
+
+        self.assertRaises(TypeError, w.tag_unbind, tag)
+        w.tag_unbind(tag, event)
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag, event), '')
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag), ())
+
+    def _test_tag_bind_rebind(self, w):
+        tag = 'sel'
+        event = '<Control-Alt-Key-d>'
+        w.pack()
+        tag_bind = w._tag_bind if isinstance(w, tkinter.Text) else w.tag_bind
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag), ())
+        self.assertEqual(tag_bind(tag, event), '')
+        def test1(e): pass
+        def test2(e): pass
+        def test3(e): pass
+
+        funcid = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test1)
+        funcid2 = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test2, add=True)
+        script = tag_bind(tag, event)
+        self.assertIn(funcid2, script)
+        self.assertIn(funcid, script)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid2)
+
+        funcid3 = w.tag_bind(tag, event, test3)
+        script = tag_bind(tag, event)
+        self.assertNotIn(funcid, script)
+        self.assertNotIn(funcid2, script)
+        self.assertIn(funcid3, script)
+        self.assertCommandExist(funcid3)
+
+    def test_canvas_tag_bind(self):
+        c = tkinter.Canvas(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_bind(c)
+
+    def test_canvas_tag_unbind(self):
+        c = tkinter.Canvas(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_unbind(c)
+
+    def test_canvas_tag_bind_rebind(self):
+        c = tkinter.Canvas(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_bind_rebind(c)
+
+    def test_text_tag_bind(self):
+        t = tkinter.Text(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_bind(t)
+
+    def test_text_tag_unbind(self):
+        t = tkinter.Text(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_unbind(t)
+
+    def test_text_tag_bind_rebind(self):
+        t = tkinter.Text(self.frame)
+        self._test_tag_bind_rebind(t)
+
     def test_bindtags(self):
         f = self.frame
         self.assertEqual(self.root.bindtags(), ('.', 'Tk', 'all'))

Lib/tkinter/__init__.py

@@ -1537,16 +1537,19 @@ def unbind(self, sequence, funcid=None):
         Otherwise destroy the current binding for SEQUENCE, leaving SEQUENCE
         unbound.
         """
+        self._unbind(('bind', self._w, sequence), funcid)
+
+    def _unbind(self, what, funcid=None):
         if funcid is None:
-            self.tk.call('bind', self._w, sequence, '')
+            self.tk.call(*what, '')
         else:
-            lines = self.tk.call('bind', self._w, sequence).split('\n')
+            lines = self.tk.call(what).split('\n')
             prefix = f'if {{"[{funcid} '
             keep = '\n'.join(line for line in lines
                              if not line.startswith(prefix))
             if not keep.strip():
                 keep = ''
-            self.tk.call('bind', self._w, sequence, keep)
+            self.tk.call(*what, keep)
             self.deletecommand(funcid)
 
     def bind_all(self, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
@@ -1558,7 +1561,7 @@ def bind_all(self, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
 
     def unbind_all(self, sequence):
         """Unbind for all widgets for event SEQUENCE all functions."""
-        self.tk.call('bind', 'all' , sequence, '')
+        self._root()._unbind(('bind', 'all', sequence))
 
     def bind_class(self, className, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
         """Bind to widgets with bindtag CLASSNAME at event
@@ -1573,7 +1576,7 @@ def bind_class(self, className, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
     def unbind_class(self, className, sequence):
         """Unbind for all widgets with bindtag CLASSNAME for event SEQUENCE
         all functions."""
-        self.tk.call('bind', className , sequence, '')
+        self._root()._unbind(('bind', className, sequence))
 
     def mainloop(self, n=0):
         """Call the mainloop of Tk."""
@@ -2885,9 +2888,7 @@ def bbox(self, *args):
     def tag_unbind(self, tagOrId, sequence, funcid=None):
         """Unbind for all items with TAGORID for event SEQUENCE  the
         function identified with FUNCID."""
-        self.tk.call(self._w, 'bind', tagOrId, sequence, '')
-        if funcid:
-            self.deletecommand(funcid)
+        self._unbind((self._w, 'bind', tagOrId, sequence), funcid)
 
     def tag_bind(self, tagOrId, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
         """Bind to all items with TAGORID at event SEQUENCE a call to function FUNC.
@@ -3997,9 +3998,7 @@ def tag_add(self, tagName, index1, *args):
     def tag_unbind(self, tagName, sequence, funcid=None):
         """Unbind for all characters with TAGNAME for event SEQUENCE  the
         function identified with FUNCID."""
-        self.tk.call(self._w, 'tag', 'bind', tagName, sequence, '')
-        if funcid:
-            self.deletecommand(funcid)
+        return self._unbind((self._w, 'tag', 'bind', tagName, sequence), funcid)
 
     def tag_bind(self, tagName, sequence, func, add=None):
         """Bind to all characters with TAGNAME at event SEQUENCE a call to function FUNC.
@@ -4010,6 +4009,11 @@ def tag_bind(self, tagName, sequence, func, add=None):
         return self._bind((self._w, 'tag', 'bind', tagName),
                   sequence, func, add)
 
+    def _tag_bind(self, tagName, sequence=None, func=None, add=None):
+        # For tests only
+        return self._bind((self._w, 'tag', 'bind', tagName),
+                  sequence, func, add)
+
     def tag_cget(self, tagName, option):
         """Return the value of OPTION for tag TAGNAME."""
         if option[:1] != '-':

Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2024-01-11-20-47-49.gh-issue-113951.AzlqFK.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+Fix the behavior of ``tag_unbind()`` methods of :class:`tkinter.Text` and
+:class:`tkinter.Canvas` classes with three arguments. Previously,
+``widget.tag_unbind(tag, sequence, funcid)`` destroyed the current binding
+for *sequence*, leaving *sequence* unbound, and deleted the *funcid*
+command. Now it removes only *funcid* from the binding for *sequence*,
+keeping other commands, and deletes the *funcid* command. It leaves
+*sequence* unbound only if *funcid* was the last bound command.