diff --git a/packages/replay/metrics/src/results/pr-comment.ts b/packages/replay/metrics/src/results/pr-comment.ts
index 618c1aa8d76e..d44d388deba8 100644
--- a/packages/replay/metrics/src/results/pr-comment.ts
+++ b/packages/replay/metrics/src/results/pr-comment.ts
@@ -84,8 +84,8 @@ export class PrCommentBuilder {
         <td align="right"><strong>${values.diff(0, 1)}</strong></td>
         <td align="right"><strong>${values.percent(0, 1)}</strong></td>
         <td align="right">${values.value(2)}</td>
-        <td align="right"><strong>${values.diff(1, 2)}</strong></td>
-        <td align="right"><strong>${values.percent(1, 2)}</strong></td>
+        <td align="right"><strong>${values.diff(0, 2)}</strong></td>
+        <td align="right"><strong>${values.percent(0, 2)}</strong></td>
       `;
     }
 
@@ -141,7 +141,7 @@ export class PrCommentBuilder {
       this._buffer += `<tr><th>${resultFile.hash}</th>`;
       for (const item of analysis.items) {
         // TODO maybe find a better way of showing this. After the change to multiple scenarios, this shows diff between "With Sentry" and "With Sentry + Replay"
-        this._buffer += `<td align="right">${item.values.diff(1, 2)}</td>`;
+        this._buffer += `<td align="right">${item.values.diff(0, 2)}</td>`;
       }
       this._buffer += '</tr>';
     }
diff --git a/packages/replay/metrics/src/util/console.ts b/packages/replay/metrics/src/util/console.ts
index 9af66f36eb90..c5674158fcc0 100644
--- a/packages/replay/metrics/src/util/console.ts
+++ b/packages/replay/metrics/src/util/console.ts
@@ -28,11 +28,11 @@ export function printAnalysis(analysis: Analysis): void {
     table[AnalyzerItemMetric[item.metric]] = {
       value: item.values.value(0),
       withSentry: item.values.diff(0, 1),
-      withReplay: item.values.diff(1, 2),
+      withReplay: item.values.diff(0, 2),
       ...((item.others == undefined) ? {} : {
         previous: item.others.value(0),
         previousWithSentry: item.others.diff(0, 1),
-        previousWithReplay: item.others.diff(1, 2)
+        previousWithReplay: item.others.diff(0, 2)
       })
     };
   }