[6.4][ML] Improve the accuracy of model memory control (#125)

Author: tveasey

docs/CHANGELOG.asciidoc

@@ -24,6 +24,7 @@ Improve behavior when there are abrupt changes in the seasonal components presen
 Explicit change point detection and modelling ({pull}92[#92])
 Improve partition analysis memory usage ({pull}97[#97])
 Reduce model memory by storing state for periodicity testing in a compressed format ({pull}100[#100])
+Improve the accuracy of model memory control ({pull}122[#122])
 
 Forecasting of Machine Learning job time series is now supported for large jobs by temporarily storing
 model state on disk ({pull}89[#89])

include/api/CAnomalyJob.h

@@ -108,10 +108,8 @@ class API_EXPORT CAnomalyJob : public CDataProcessor {
 public:
     using TPersistCompleteFunc =
         std::function<void(const CModelSnapshotJsonWriter::SModelSnapshotReport&)>;
-    using TAnomalyDetectorPtr = model::CAnomalyDetector::TAnomalyDetectorPtr;
+    using TAnomalyDetectorPtr = std::shared_ptr<model::CAnomalyDetector>;
     using TAnomalyDetectorPtrVec = std::vector<TAnomalyDetectorPtr>;
-    using TAnomalyDetectorPtrVecItr = std::vector<TAnomalyDetectorPtr>::iterator;
-    using TAnomalyDetectorPtrVecCItr = std::vector<TAnomalyDetectorPtr>::const_iterator;
     using TKeyVec = std::vector<model::CSearchKey>;
     using TKeyAnomalyDetectorPtrUMap =
         boost::unordered_map<model::CSearchKey::TStrKeyPr, TAnomalyDetectorPtr, model::CStrKeyPrHash, model::CStrKeyPrEqual>;
@@ -359,7 +357,7 @@ class API_EXPORT CAnomalyJob : public CDataProcessor {
     //! Update configuration
     void doForecast(const std::string& controlMessage);
 
-    model::CAnomalyDetector::TAnomalyDetectorPtr
+    TAnomalyDetectorPtr
     makeDetector(int identifier,
                  const model::CAnomalyDetectorModelConfig& modelConfig,
                  model::CLimits& limits,

include/api/CForecastRunner.h

@@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ class API_EXPORT CForecastRunner final : private core::CNonCopyable {
     using TOStreamConcurrentWrapper = core::CConcurrentWrapper<std::ostream>;
     using TOStreamConcurrentWrapperPtr = std::shared_ptr<TOStreamConcurrentWrapper>;
 
-    using TAnomalyDetectorPtr = model::CAnomalyDetector::TAnomalyDetectorPtr;
+    using TAnomalyDetectorPtr = std::shared_ptr<model::CAnomalyDetector>;
     using TAnomalyDetectorPtrVec = std::vector<TAnomalyDetectorPtr>;
 
     using TForecastModelWrapper = model::CForecastDataSink::SForecastModelWrapper;

include/model/CAnomalyDetector.h

@@ -70,14 +70,9 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CAnomalyDetector : private core::CNonCopyable {
     using TStrVec = std::vector<std::string>;
     using TStrCPtrVec = std::vector<const std::string*>;
     using TModelPlotDataVec = std::vector<CModelPlotData>;
-
     using TDataGathererPtr = std::shared_ptr<CDataGatherer>;
     using TModelFactoryCPtr = std::shared_ptr<const CModelFactory>;
     using TModelPtr = std::unique_ptr<CAnomalyDetectorModel>;
-
-    //! A shared pointer to an instance of this class
-    using TAnomalyDetectorPtr = std::shared_ptr<CAnomalyDetector>;
-
     using TOutputModelPlotDataFunc =
         std::function<void(const std::string&, const std::string&, const std::string&, const std::string&, const CModelPlotData&)>;
     using TStrSet = CAnomalyDetectorModelConfig::TStrSet;
@@ -334,14 +329,13 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CAnomalyDetector : private core::CNonCopyable {
     //! in the model ensemble class.
     void legacyModelsAcceptPersistInserter(core::CStatePersistInserter& inserter) const;
 
-protected:
-    //! Configurable limits
-    CLimits& m_Limits;
-
 private:
     //! An identifier for the search for which this is detecting anomalies.
     int m_DetectorIndex;
 
+    //! Configurable limits
+    CLimits& m_Limits;
+
     //! Configurable behaviour
     const CAnomalyDetectorModelConfig& m_ModelConfig;
 

include/model/CDataGatherer.h

@@ -108,36 +108,24 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     using TSizeUInt64Pr = std::pair<std::size_t, uint64_t>;
     using TSizeUInt64PrVec = std::vector<TSizeUInt64Pr>;
     using TFeatureVec = model_t::TFeatureVec;
-    using TFeatureVecCItr = TFeatureVec::const_iterator;
     using TSizeSizePr = std::pair<std::size_t, std::size_t>;
     using TSizeSizePrUInt64Pr = std::pair<TSizeSizePr, uint64_t>;
     using TSizeSizePrUInt64PrVec = std::vector<TSizeSizePrUInt64Pr>;
     using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMap = boost::unordered_map<TSizeSizePr, uint64_t>;
-    using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapItr = TSizeSizePrUInt64UMap::iterator;
-    using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapCItr = TSizeSizePrUInt64UMap::const_iterator;
     using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueue = CBucketQueue<TSizeSizePrUInt64UMap>;
-    using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueueItr = TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueue::iterator;
-    using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueueCItr = TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueue::const_iterator;
-    using TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueueCRItr = TSizeSizePrUInt64UMapQueue::const_reverse_iterator;
     using TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMap = CBucketGatherer::TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMap;
-    using TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMapCItr =
-        TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMap::const_iterator;
-    using TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMapItr =
-        TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMap::iterator;
     using TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMapVec =
         std::vector<TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMap>;
     using TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMapVecQueue =
         CBucketQueue<TSizeSizePrStoredStringPtrPrUInt64UMapVec>;
     using TSearchKeyCRef = boost::reference_wrapper<const CSearchKey>;
-    using TBucketGathererPVec = std::vector<CBucketGatherer*>;
-    using TBucketGathererPVecItr = TBucketGathererPVec::iterator;
-    using TBucketGathererPVecCItr = TBucketGathererPVec::const_iterator;
+    using TBucketGathererPtr = std::unique_ptr<CBucketGatherer>;
+    using TBucketGathererPtrVec = std::vector<TBucketGathererPtr>;
     using TFeatureAnyPr = std::pair<model_t::EFeature, boost::any>;
     using TFeatureAnyPrVec = std::vector<TFeatureAnyPr>;
     using TMetricCategoryVec = std::vector<model_t::EMetricCategory>;
-    using TSampleCountsPtr = std::shared_ptr<CSampleCounts>;
+    using TSampleCountsPtr = std::unique_ptr<CSampleCounts>;
     using TTimeVec = std::vector<core_t::TTime>;
-    using TTimeVecCItr = TTimeVec::const_iterator;
 
 public:
     //! The summary count indicating an explicit null record.
@@ -161,8 +149,6 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     //! \param[in] modelParams The global configuration parameters.
     //! \param[in] summaryCountFieldName If \p summaryMode is E_Manual
     //! then this is the name of the field holding the summary count.
-    //! \param[in] partitionFieldName The name of the field which splits
-    //! the data.
     //! \param[in] partitionFieldValue The value of the field which splits
     //! the data.
     //! \param[in] personFieldName The name of the field which identifies
@@ -173,8 +159,6 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     //! the metric values.
     //! \param[in] influenceFieldNames The field names for which we will
     //! compute influences.
-    //! \param[in] useNull If true the gatherer will process missing
-    //! person and attribute field values (assuming they are empty).
     //! \param[in] key The key of the search for which to gatherer data.
     //! \param[in] features The features of the data to model.
     //! \param[in] startTime The start of the time interval for which
@@ -187,13 +171,11 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
                   model_t::ESummaryMode summaryMode,
                   const SModelParams& modelParams,
                   const std::string& summaryCountFieldName,
-                  const std::string& partitionFieldName,
                   const std::string& partitionFieldValue,
                   const std::string& personFieldName,
                   const std::string& attributeFieldName,
                   const std::string& valueFieldName,
                   const TStrVec& influenceFieldNames,
-                  bool useNull,
                   const CSearchKey& key,
                   const TFeatureVec& features,
                   core_t::TTime startTime,
@@ -204,13 +186,11 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
                   model_t::ESummaryMode summaryMode,
                   const SModelParams& modelParams,
                   const std::string& summaryCountFieldName,
-                  const std::string& partitionFieldName,
                   const std::string& partitionFieldValue,
                   const std::string& personFieldName,
                   const std::string& attributeFieldName,
                   const std::string& valueFieldName,
                   const TStrVec& influenceFieldNames,
-                  bool useNull,
                   const CSearchKey& key,
                   core::CStateRestoreTraverser& traverser);
 
@@ -220,8 +200,9 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     //! redundant except to create a signature that will not be mistaken for
     //! a general purpose copy constructor.
     CDataGatherer(bool isForPersistence, const CDataGatherer& other);
-
     ~CDataGatherer();
+    CDataGatherer(const CDataGatherer&) = delete;
+    CDataGatherer& operator=(const CDataGatherer&) = delete;
     //@}
 
     //! \name Persistence
@@ -546,7 +527,7 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     void resetSampleCount(std::size_t id);
 
     //! Get the sample counts.
-    TSampleCountsPtr sampleCounts() const;
+    const TSampleCountsPtr& sampleCounts() const;
     //@}
 
     //! \name Time
@@ -759,7 +740,7 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
 
     //! The collection of bucket gatherers which contain the bucket-specific
     //! metrics and counts.
-    TBucketGathererPVec m_Gatherers;
+    TBucketGathererPtrVec m_Gatherers;
 
     //! Indicates whether the data being gathered are already summarized
     //! by an external aggregation process.
@@ -768,15 +749,12 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CDataGatherer {
     //! The global configuration parameters.
     TModelParamsCRef m_Params;
 
-    //! The partition field name or an empty string if there isn't one.
-    std::string m_PartitionFieldName;
+    //! The key of the search for which data is being gathered.
+    TSearchKeyCRef m_SearchKey;
 
     //! The value of the partition field for this detector.
     core::CStoredStringPtr m_PartitionFieldValue;
 
-    //! The key of the search for which data is being gathered.
-    TSearchKeyCRef m_SearchKey;
-
     //! A registry where person names are mapped to unique IDs.
     CDynamicStringIdRegistry m_PeopleRegistry;
 

include/model/CLimits.h

@@ -64,10 +64,7 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CLimits {
 
 public:
     //! Default constructor
-    CLimits();
-
-    //! Default destructor
-    ~CLimits();
+    explicit CLimits(double byteLimitMargin = CResourceMonitor::DEFAULT_BYTE_LIMIT_MARGIN);
 
     //! Initialise from a config file.  This overwrites current settings
     //! with any found in the config file.  Settings that are not present

include/model/CResourceMonitor.h

@@ -11,8 +11,9 @@
 #include <model/ImportExport.h>
 #include <model/ModelTypes.h>
 
+#include <boost/unordered_map.hpp>
+
 #include <functional>
-#include <map>
 
 class CResourceMonitorTest;
 class CResourceLimitTest;
@@ -42,20 +43,21 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CResourceMonitor {
     };
 
 public:
-    using TModelPtrSizePr = std::pair<CAnomalyDetectorModel*, std::size_t>;
-    using TModelPtrSizeMap = std::map<CAnomalyDetectorModel*, std::size_t>;
+    using TDetectorPtrSizePr = std::pair<CAnomalyDetector*, std::size_t>;
+    using TDetectorPtrSizeUMap = boost::unordered_map<CAnomalyDetector*, std::size_t>;
     using TMemoryUsageReporterFunc = std::function<void(const CResourceMonitor::SResults&)>;
     using TTimeSizeMap = std::map<core_t::TTime, std::size_t>;
 
     //! The minimum time between prunes
     static const core_t::TTime MINIMUM_PRUNE_FREQUENCY;
-
     //! Default memory limit for resource monitor
     static const std::size_t DEFAULT_MEMORY_LIMIT_MB;
+    //! The initial byte limit margin to use if none is supplied
+    static const double DEFAULT_BYTE_LIMIT_MARGIN;
 
 public:
     //! Default constructor
-    CResourceMonitor();
+    explicit CResourceMonitor(double byteLimitMargin = DEFAULT_BYTE_LIMIT_MARGIN);
 
     //! Query the resource monitor to find out if the models are
     //! taking up too much memory and further allocations should be banned
@@ -127,13 +129,21 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CResourceMonitor {
     //! Clears all extra memory
     void clearExtraMemory();
 
+    //! Decrease the margin on the memory limit.
+    //!
+    //! We start off applying a margin to the memory limit because
+    //! it is difficult to accurately estimate the long term memory
+    //! usage at this point. This is gradually decreased over time
+    //! by calling this pnce per bucket processed.
+    void decreaseMargin(core_t::TTime elapsedTime);
+
 private:
     //! Updates the memory limit fields and the prune threshold
     //! to the given value.
     void updateMemoryLimitsAndPruneThreshold(std::size_t limitMBs);
 
     //! Update the given model and recalculate the total usage
-    void memUsage(CAnomalyDetectorModel* model);
+    void memUsage(CAnomalyDetector* detector);
 
     //! Determine if we need to send a usage report, based on
     //! increased usage, or increased errors
@@ -143,16 +153,25 @@ class MODEL_EXPORT CResourceMonitor {
     //! shoule be allowed or not
     void updateAllowAllocations();
 
+    //! Get the high memory limit with margin applied.
+    std::size_t highLimit() const;
+
+    //! Get the low memory limit with margin applied.
+    std::size_t lowLimit() const;
+
     //! Returns the sum of used memory plus any extra memory
     std::size_t totalMemory() const;
 
 private:
     //! The registered collection of components
-    TModelPtrSizeMap m_Models;
+    TDetectorPtrSizeUMap m_Detectors;
 
     //! Is there enough free memory to allow creating new components
     bool m_AllowAllocations;
 
+    //! The relative margin to apply to the byte limits.
+    double m_ByteLimitMargin;
+
     //! The upper limit for memory usage, checked on increasing values
     std::size_t m_ByteLimitHigh;
 

lib/api/CAnomalyJob.cc

@@ -409,6 +409,7 @@ void CAnomalyJob::outputBucketResultsUntil(core_t::TTime time) {
          lastBucketEndTime + bucketLength + latency <= time;
          lastBucketEndTime += effectiveBucketLength) {
         this->outputResults(lastBucketEndTime);
+        m_Limits.resourceMonitor().decreaseMargin(bucketLength);
         m_Limits.resourceMonitor().sendMemoryUsageReportIfSignificantlyChanged(lastBucketEndTime);
         m_LastFinalisedBucketEndTime = lastBucketEndTime + effectiveBucketLength;
 
@@ -1399,7 +1400,7 @@ CAnomalyJob::detectorForKey(bool isRestoring,
     // Check if we need to and are allowed to create a new detector.
     if (itr == m_Detectors.end() && resourceMonitor.areAllocationsAllowed()) {
         // Create an placeholder for the anomaly detector.
-        model::CAnomalyDetector::TAnomalyDetectorPtr& detector =
+        TAnomalyDetectorPtr& detector =
             m_Detectors
                 .emplace(model::CSearchKey::TStrKeyPr(partition, key), TAnomalyDetectorPtr())
                 .first->second;
@@ -1446,7 +1447,7 @@ void CAnomalyJob::pruneAllModels() {
     }
 }
 
-model::CAnomalyDetector::TAnomalyDetectorPtr
+CAnomalyJob::TAnomalyDetectorPtr
 CAnomalyJob::makeDetector(int identifier,
                           const model::CAnomalyDetectorModelConfig& modelConfig,
                           model::CLimits& limits,