Commit 3bcccb6
authored
[Reassociate] Drop weight reduction to fix issue 91417 (llvm#91469)
See the following case: https://alive2.llvm.org/ce/z/A-fBki
```
define i3 @src(i3 %0) {
%2 = mul i3 %0, %0
%3 = mul i3 %2, %0
%4 = mul i3 %3, %0
%5 = mul nsw i3 %4, %0
ret i3 %5
}
define i3 @tgt(i3 %0) {
%2 = mul i3 %0, %0
%5 = mul nsw i3 %2, %0
ret i3 %5
}
```
llvm@d7aeefe
introduced weight reduction during weights combination of the same
operand. As the weight of `%0` changes from 5 to 3, the nsw flag in `%5`
should be dropped.
However, the nsw flag isn't cleared by `RewriteExprTree` since `%5 = mul
nsw i3 %0, %4` is not included in the range of `[ExpressionChangedStart,
ExpressionChangedEnd)`.
```
Calculated Rank[] = 3
Combine negations for: %2 = mul i3 %0, %0
Calculated Rank[] = 4
Combine negations for: %3 = mul i3 %0, %2
Calculated Rank[] = 5
Combine negations for: %4 = mul i3 %0, %3
Calculated Rank[] = 6
Combine negations for: %5 = mul nsw i3 %0, %4
LINEARIZE: %5 = mul nsw i3 %0, %4
OPERAND: i3 %0 (1)
ADD USES LEAF: i3 %0 (1)
OPERAND: %4 = mul i3 %0, %3 (1)
DIRECT ADD: %4 = mul i3 %0, %3 (1)
OPERAND: i3 %0 (1)
OPERAND: %3 = mul i3 %0, %2 (1)
DIRECT ADD: %3 = mul i3 %0, %2 (1)
OPERAND: i3 %0 (1)
OPERAND: %2 = mul i3 %0, %0 (1)
DIRECT ADD: %2 = mul i3 %0, %0 (1)
OPERAND: i3 %0 (1)
OPERAND: i3 %0 (1)
RAIn: mul i3 [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3]
RAOut: mul i3 [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3]
RAOut after CSE reorder: mul i3 [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3] [ %0, #3]
RA: %5 = mul nsw i3 %0, %4
TO: %5 = mul nsw i3 %4, %0
RA: %4 = mul i3 %0, %3
TO: %4 = mul i3 %0, %0
```
The best way to fix this is to inform `RewriteExprTree` to clear flags
of the whole expr tree when weight reduction happens.
But I find that weight reduction based on Carmichael number never
happens in practice.
See the coverage result
https://dtcxzyw.github.io/llvm-opt-benchmark/coverage/home/dtcxzyw/llvm-project/llvm/lib/Transforms/Scalar/Reassociate.cpp.html#L323
I think it would be better to drop `IncorporateWeight`.
Fixes llvm#914171 parent 971f1aa commit 3bcccb6
File tree
2 files changed
+126
-173
lines changed- llvm
- lib/Transforms/Scalar
- test/Transforms/Reassociate
2 files changed
+126
-173
lines changed| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| |||
302 | 302 | | |
303 | 303 | | |
304 | 304 | | |
305 | | - | |
306 | | - | |
307 | | - | |
308 | | - | |
309 | | - | |
310 | | - | |
311 | | - | |
312 | | - | |
313 | | - | |
314 | | - | |
315 | | - | |
316 | | - | |
317 | | - | |
318 | | - | |
319 | | - | |
320 | | - | |
321 | | - | |
322 | | - | |
323 | | - | |
324 | | - | |
325 | | - | |
326 | | - | |
327 | | - | |
328 | | - | |
329 | | - | |
330 | | - | |
331 | | - | |
332 | | - | |
333 | | - | |
334 | | - | |
335 | | - | |
336 | | - | |
337 | | - | |
338 | | - | |
339 | | - | |
340 | | - | |
341 | | - | |
342 | | - | |
343 | | - | |
344 | | - | |
345 | | - | |
346 | | - | |
347 | | - | |
348 | | - | |
349 | | - | |
350 | | - | |
351 | | - | |
352 | | - | |
353 | | - | |
354 | | - | |
355 | | - | |
356 | | - | |
357 | | - | |
358 | | - | |
359 | | - | |
360 | | - | |
361 | | - | |
362 | | - | |
363 | | - | |
364 | | - | |
365 | | - | |
366 | | - | |
367 | | - | |
368 | | - | |
369 | | - | |
370 | | - | |
371 | | - | |
372 | | - | |
373 | | - | |
374 | | - | |
375 | | - | |
376 | | - | |
377 | | - | |
378 | | - | |
379 | | - | |
380 | | - | |
381 | | - | |
382 | | - | |
383 | | - | |
384 | | - | |
385 | | - | |
386 | | - | |
387 | | - | |
388 | | - | |
389 | | - | |
390 | | - | |
391 | | - | |
392 | | - | |
393 | | - | |
394 | | - | |
395 | | - | |
396 | 305 | | |
397 | 306 | | |
398 | 307 | | |
| |||
562 | 471 | | |
563 | 472 | | |
564 | 473 | | |
565 | | - | |
566 | | - | |
567 | | - | |
568 | | - | |
569 | | - | |
570 | | - | |
571 | | - | |
572 | | - | |
573 | | - | |
574 | | - | |
575 | | - | |
576 | | - | |
577 | | - | |
578 | | - | |
579 | | - | |
580 | | - | |
581 | | - | |
582 | | - | |
583 | | - | |
584 | | - | |
| 474 | + | |
585 | 475 | | |
586 | 476 | | |
587 | 477 | | |
| |||
0 commit comments